16 March 2022

1. The Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (“CCCS”) has today issued a Proposed Infringement Decision (“PID”)^[1] against the following Parties for infringing section 34 of the Competition Act 2004 (the “Act”) ^[2]:

a) CNL Logistic Solutions Pte. Ltd. (“CNL”);

b) Gilmon Transportation & Warehousing Pte Ltd (“Gilmon”);

c) Penanshin (PSA KD) Pte. Ltd. (“Penanshin”); and

d) Mac-Nels (KD) Terminal Pte Ltd (“Mac-Nels”)

CCCS proposes to find that the Parties have engaged in anti-competitive coordination to fix the price of warehousing services at Keppel Distripark^[3] by imposing an “FTZ Surcharge”^[4] (the “Price Fixing Conduct”).

2. In August 2018, CCCS commenced an investigation following a complaint about possible price fixing at Keppel Distripark. CCCS found that between 15 and 16 June 2017, representatives of the Parties had communicated with one another on their respective plans to implement an identically named and priced “FTZ Surcharge”. This “FTZ Surcharge” was charged to their customers for the provision of warehousing services for import cargo. In doing so, the Parties knowingly substituted the risks of price competition in favour of practical cooperation between them and did not determine their prices independently.

3. CCCS’s investigations revealed that the Price Fixing Conduct occurred from 15 June 2017 to 19 November 2019. CCCS considers the Price Fixing Conduct to be, by its very nature, harmful to competition. Businesses should independently determine their prices or pricing strategies, including whether to impose any surcharge and the quantum of such surcharge.

4. The Parties (including those who applied for lenient treatment under CCCS’s Leniency Programme)^[5] have six weeks from the receipt of the PID to make representations to CCCS. CCCS will carefully consider the representations, as well as all available information and evidence, before making its decision.
______________________________

^[1] The PID is a written notice setting out the facts on which CCCS makes its assessment and its reasons for arriving at the proposed decision. It is issued to Parties to assist them to make representations and provide any other information in support of their representations for CCCS’s consideration.

^[2] Section 34 of the Act prohibits any agreements between undertakings, decisions by associations of undertakings or concerted practices which have as their object or effect the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition within Singapore. An undertaking means any person, being an individual, a body corporate, an unincorporated body of persons or any other entity, capable of carrying on commercial or economic activities relating to goods or services.

^[3] Keppel Distripark is a cargo distribution complex located at Kampong Bahru Road comprising various warehousing and office facilities and is directly linked to the container terminals at Pulau Brani, Keppel, Tanjong Pagar and Pasir Panjang.

^[4] “FTZ Surcharge” being the name coined by the Parties for this surcharge.

^[5] Please refer to the Appendix below for more information on CCCS’s Leniency Programme.